At first glance, Nutter Butter’s TikTok presence is, in a word, confusing. Its highest-viewed video, at 12.3 million views, features eerie music and a slideshow of a Nutter Butter family.

Now create a crust on the bottom of each paper by combining crushed cookies -- any hard, crunchy cookie (think nutter butter or store ... caramels, and plain chocolates freeze well.