“Menthol is a well-known mild topical anesthetic,” adds board-certified dermatologist Heather Woolery-Lloyd, MD, ... Dove Deep Moisture Body Wash. $10 at Amazon. Credit: Walmart.

If you're all about a great value, pick up Solimo's Clarifying Pink Grapefruit Body Wash.A big, 8.5-ounce bottle will set you back just $4, so you can keep every bathroom in the house stocked.