Shop Old-Style Banana Taffy

Sponsored
$19.99
Banana Taffy - 2 Pounds Of Sweet Chewy Individually Wrapped Bulk Taffy Candy
Amazon.com
61
$19.99
Banana Taffy - 2 Pounds Of Sweet Chewy Individually Wrapped Bulk Taffy Candy
Amazon.com
61
$24.60
Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Banana (Yellow/Brown/Yellow)
Walmart
$24.60
Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Banana (Yellow/Brown/Yellow)
Walmart
$29.95
Banana Salt Water Taffy
Hall's Candies
$29.95
Banana Salt Water Taffy
Hall's Candies
$17.95
Banana Split Taffy, 2 Pound Bag - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$17.95
Banana Split Taffy, 2 Pound Bag - The Vermont Country Store
Vermont Country Store
Special Offer
$18.90
Sweet Candy Company Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped - Salt Water Taffy Candy Bulk, Old Fashioned Banana Flavor, Soft And Chewy, Single Flavor
Amazon.com
14K+
$18.90
Sweet Candy Company Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped - Salt Water Taffy Candy Bulk, Old Fashioned Banana Flavor, Soft And Chewy, Single Flavor
Amazon.com
14K+
$25.12
Laffy Taffy Candy, Banana Flavor, Individually Wrapped Candy (145 Pieces)
Amazon.com
24K+
$25.12
Laffy Taffy Candy, Banana Flavor, Individually Wrapped Candy (145 Pieces)
Amazon.com
24K+
$6.50
Laffy Taffy Gone Bananas Limited Edition Chewy Candy Banana Flavored Candies, 3.5 Oz Birthday Halloween Christmas Party Treats And Stocking Stuffer -
Walmart
Free shipping
$6.50
Laffy Taffy Gone Bananas Limited Edition Chewy Candy Banana Flavored Candies, 3.5 Oz Birthday Halloween Christmas Party Treats And Stocking Stuffer -
Walmart
Free shipping
$24.60
Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Vanilla (Pink/White/Brown)
Walmart
$24.60
Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Vanilla (Pink/White/Brown)
Walmart
$20.60
Bit-O-Honey Retro Taffy Candy, Individually Wrapped (Pack Of 3 Pounds)
Amazon.com
352
$20.60
Bit-O-Honey Retro Taffy Candy, Individually Wrapped (Pack Of 3 Pounds)
Amazon.com
352
$15.57
Bananarama, Banana Candy 2 Pounds
Amazon.com
2K+
$15.57
Bananarama, Banana Candy 2 Pounds
Amazon.com
2K+
$14.99
Sugar Free Banana Salt Water Taffy - 1Lb (16Oz) Bulk Bag Individually Wrapped Soft & Chewy Nut Free, Gluten Free,Diabetic & Keto Friendly Gourmet
Amazon.com
118
$14.99
Sugar Free Banana Salt Water Taffy - 1Lb (16Oz) Bulk Bag Individually Wrapped Soft & Chewy Nut Free, Gluten Free,Diabetic & Keto Friendly Gourmet
Amazon.com
118
$2.98
Nostalgic 1923 Original Banana Turkish Taffy 24CT Box
Faire
$2.98
Nostalgic 1923 Original Banana Turkish Taffy 24CT Box
Faire
$15.50
Banana Split Taffy - 3Lb
Blair Candy Company
$15.50
Banana Split Taffy - 3Lb
Blair Candy Company
$15.95
Taffy Town Salt Water Taffy (Banana Split, 1 Lb)
Walmart
Free shipping
$15.95
Taffy Town Salt Water Taffy (Banana Split, 1 Lb)
Walmart
Free shipping
$24.99
Laffee Taffy 3Lb Bag Of Delicious Assortment - Cherry, Sour Apple, & Banana Flavors - Freshly Packed By Snackadilly
Amazon.com
235
$24.99
Laffee Taffy 3Lb Bag Of Delicious Assortment - Cherry, Sour Apple, & Banana Flavors - Freshly Packed By Snackadilly
Amazon.com
235
$14.99
Gourmet Yellow Banana Soft Taffy Chews By It's Delish, 8 Oz Half Pound Bag
Walmart
Free shipping
$14.99
Gourmet Yellow Banana Soft Taffy Chews By It's Delish, 8 Oz Half Pound Bag
Walmart
Free shipping
$13.95
Banana Split Candy Chews 140Ct
Blair Candy Company
1
$13.95
Banana Split Candy Chews 140Ct
Blair Candy Company
1
$10.75
Laffy Taffy Ropes 24Ct Banana
Blair Candy Company
6K+
$10.75
Laffy Taffy Ropes 24Ct Banana
Blair Candy Company
6K+
$1.00
Nostalgic 1975 Original LAFFY TAFFY "BANANA" 24CT Box
Faire
$1.00
Nostalgic 1975 Original LAFFY TAFFY "BANANA" 24CT Box
Faire
$29.95
Assorted Salt Water Taffy
Hall's Candies
$29.95
Assorted Salt Water Taffy
Hall's Candies
$21.36
Old Fashioned Taffy - Banana - 3 LB. Bag
Etsy
$21.36
Old Fashioned Taffy - Banana - 3 LB. Bag
Etsy
$18.92
Banana Shaped Candy, Crazy Rainbow Assortment, 3 Pounds Bulk
Amazon.com
$18.92
Banana Shaped Candy, Crazy Rainbow Assortment, 3 Pounds Bulk
Amazon.com
$17.99
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Variety Bundle, 8 Pack (4 Flavors), Strawberry Taffy, Vanilla Taffy, Chocolate Taffy, Banana Taffy, Individually Wrapped Taffy Ca
Walmart
$17.99
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Variety Bundle, 8 Pack (4 Flavors), Strawberry Taffy, Vanilla Taffy, Chocolate Taffy, Banana Taffy, Individually Wrapped Taffy Ca
Walmart
$39.99
Annabelle's Abba-Zaba Chewy Taffy Peanut Butter Center, 1.8-Ounce Bars (Pack Of 24)
Amazon.com
116
Free shipping
$39.99
Annabelle's Abba-Zaba Chewy Taffy Peanut Butter Center, 1.8-Ounce Bars (Pack Of 24)
Amazon.com
116
$0.16
The Original Banana Split Taffy, 140Ct Box
Faire
$0.16
The Original Banana Split Taffy, 140Ct Box
Faire
$15.50
Sweet's Salt Water Taffy Banana 3Lb Bag
Blair Candy Company
$15.50
Sweet's Salt Water Taffy Banana 3Lb Bag
Blair Candy Company
$14.49
Necco Banana Split Chews, 10.5 Oz.
Walmart
2
Free shipping
$14.49
Necco Banana Split Chews, 10.5 Oz.
Walmart
2
$30.95
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Banana 24Ct
Blair Candy Company
2
$30.95
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Banana 24Ct
Blair Candy Company
2
$18.69
HI-CHEW Banana - Box Of 15 Sticks, 1.76Oz Ea | Unique Fun Soft & Chewy Taffy Candy | Immensely Juicy Fruit Flavors
Amazon.com
6K+
$18.69
HI-CHEW Banana - Box Of 15 Sticks, 1.76Oz Ea | Unique Fun Soft & Chewy Taffy Candy | Immensely Juicy Fruit Flavors
Amazon.com
6K+
$2.00
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Banana, 1.5Oz, 24Ct Case
Faire
$2.00
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Banana, 1.5Oz, 24Ct Case
Faire
$5.99
Laffy Taffy Gone Bananas Candy 3.5 Oz
Walmart
Free shipping
$5.99
Laffy Taffy Gone Bananas Candy 3.5 Oz
Walmart
Free shipping
$15.99
Necco Yellow Banana Split Candy Chews 1LB Bag
Walmart
8
$15.99
Necco Yellow Banana Split Candy Chews 1LB Bag
Walmart
8
$20.98
$21.99
145 Pc Bulk Laffy Taffy Banana Mini Bar Tub
Oriental Trading Company
7
$20.98
$21.99
145 Pc Bulk Laffy Taffy Banana Mini Bar Tub
Oriental Trading Company
7
$32.99
BIT-O-HONEY Candy 5 Lb - Bulk Bag, Retro Taffy, Honey & Almond Flavor, Soft Chewy, Individually Wrapped
Amazon.com
90
$32.99
BIT-O-HONEY Candy 5 Lb - Bulk Bag, Retro Taffy, Honey & Almond Flavor, Soft Chewy, Individually Wrapped
Amazon.com
90
$23.99
Laffy Taffy Banana 145 Pieces Tub
Walmart
58
Free shipping
$23.99
Laffy Taffy Banana 145 Pieces Tub
Walmart
58
$18.28
Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars Sugar Free 2Lb Bag
Amazon.com
1K+
$18.28
Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars Sugar Free 2Lb Bag
Amazon.com
1K+
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop Old-Style Banana Taffy

    Sponsored
    $19.99
    Banana Taffy - 2 Pounds Of Sweet Chewy Individually Wrapped Bulk Taffy Candy
    Amazon.com
    61
    $19.99
    Banana Taffy - 2 Pounds Of Sweet Chewy Individually Wrapped Bulk Taffy Candy
    Amazon.com
    61
    $24.60
    Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Banana (Yellow/Brown/Yellow)
    Walmart
    $24.60
    Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Banana (Yellow/Brown/Yellow)
    Walmart
    $29.95
    Banana Salt Water Taffy
    Hall's Candies
    $29.95
    Banana Salt Water Taffy
    Hall's Candies
    $17.95
    Banana Split Taffy, 2 Pound Bag - The Vermont Country Store
    Vermont Country Store
    Special Offer
    $17.95
    Banana Split Taffy, 2 Pound Bag - The Vermont Country Store
    Vermont Country Store
    Special Offer
    $18.90
    Sweet Candy Company Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped - Salt Water Taffy Candy Bulk, Old Fashioned Banana Flavor, Soft And Chewy, Single Flavor
    Amazon.com
    14K+
    $18.90
    Sweet Candy Company Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped - Salt Water Taffy Candy Bulk, Old Fashioned Banana Flavor, Soft And Chewy, Single Flavor
    Amazon.com
    14K+
    $25.12
    Laffy Taffy Candy, Banana Flavor, Individually Wrapped Candy (145 Pieces)
    Amazon.com
    24K+
    $25.12
    Laffy Taffy Candy, Banana Flavor, Individually Wrapped Candy (145 Pieces)
    Amazon.com
    24K+
    $6.50
    Laffy Taffy Gone Bananas Limited Edition Chewy Candy Banana Flavored Candies, 3.5 Oz Birthday Halloween Christmas Party Treats And Stocking Stuffer -
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $6.50
    Laffy Taffy Gone Bananas Limited Edition Chewy Candy Banana Flavored Candies, 3.5 Oz Birthday Halloween Christmas Party Treats And Stocking Stuffer -
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $24.60
    Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Vanilla (Pink/White/Brown)
    Walmart
    $24.60
    Mccraw's 3Pack Mccraws Huge Flat Taffy - - Vanilla (Pink/White/Brown)
    Walmart
    $20.60
    Bit-O-Honey Retro Taffy Candy, Individually Wrapped (Pack Of 3 Pounds)
    Amazon.com
    352
    $20.60
    Bit-O-Honey Retro Taffy Candy, Individually Wrapped (Pack Of 3 Pounds)
    Amazon.com
    352
    $15.57
    Bananarama, Banana Candy 2 Pounds
    Amazon.com
    2K+
    $15.57
    Bananarama, Banana Candy 2 Pounds
    Amazon.com
    2K+
    $14.99
    Sugar Free Banana Salt Water Taffy - 1Lb (16Oz) Bulk Bag Individually Wrapped Soft & Chewy Nut Free, Gluten Free,Diabetic & Keto Friendly Gourmet
    Amazon.com
    118
    $14.99
    Sugar Free Banana Salt Water Taffy - 1Lb (16Oz) Bulk Bag Individually Wrapped Soft & Chewy Nut Free, Gluten Free,Diabetic & Keto Friendly Gourmet
    Amazon.com
    118
    $2.98
    Nostalgic 1923 Original Banana Turkish Taffy 24CT Box
    Faire
    $2.98
    Nostalgic 1923 Original Banana Turkish Taffy 24CT Box
    Faire
    $15.50
    Banana Split Taffy - 3Lb
    Blair Candy Company
    $15.50
    Banana Split Taffy - 3Lb
    Blair Candy Company
    $15.95
    Taffy Town Salt Water Taffy (Banana Split, 1 Lb)
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $15.95
    Taffy Town Salt Water Taffy (Banana Split, 1 Lb)
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $24.99
    Laffee Taffy 3Lb Bag Of Delicious Assortment - Cherry, Sour Apple, & Banana Flavors - Freshly Packed By Snackadilly
    Amazon.com
    235
    $24.99
    Laffee Taffy 3Lb Bag Of Delicious Assortment - Cherry, Sour Apple, & Banana Flavors - Freshly Packed By Snackadilly
    Amazon.com
    235
    $14.99
    Gourmet Yellow Banana Soft Taffy Chews By It's Delish, 8 Oz Half Pound Bag
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $14.99
    Gourmet Yellow Banana Soft Taffy Chews By It's Delish, 8 Oz Half Pound Bag
    Walmart
    Free shipping
    $13.95
    Banana Split Candy Chews 140Ct
    Blair Candy Company
    1
    $13.95
    Banana Split Candy Chews 140Ct
    Blair Candy Company
    1
    $10.75
    Laffy Taffy Ropes 24Ct Banana
    Blair Candy Company
    6K+
    $10.75
    Laffy Taffy Ropes 24Ct Banana
    Blair Candy Company
    6K+